NEW YORK, NY — EdTrust-New York is deeply concerned by 2025-26 state assessment results released this week, which show a significant decline in student reading outcomes. We also have serious concerns about the state’s overall assessment system, including its lack of transparency and ongoing questions about the reliability of state data.
Student Outcomes
The 2025-26 state assessment results show a significant decline in reading outcomes across the state, particularly among third graders. In 2024-25, statewide third-grade proficiency rates appeared to show encouraging progress, increasing 11 percentage points to 54%. This year, however, proficiency fell to just 42%, a 12-percentage-point decline. Although this fluctuation is highly unusual, it underscores the urgent need for stronger state leadership and action to ensure all students receive the evidence-based literacy instruction and support they deserve.
Reliability of Scores
NYSED has yet to fully explain the significant and unusual fluctuation in scores between the 2024-25 and 2025-26 school years. NYSED briefly addressed the fluctuation in its press release, suggesting they were “unexpected” and “unusual patterns,” with no explanation of why. We continue to call for an independent audit of the last three years of ELA testing. An audit would help the public better understand the testing protocols, scaling and scoring methodologies, and standard-setting processes that produced these results.
Public Transparency
Once again, NYSED released this critical information through a press release with no public presentation or analysis of outcomes as has been done in the past. NYSED also plans to release disaggregated data more than six months after students took exams. This delay is far too long. Educators, families and policy makers need timely access to these data to make informed decisions and understand how students across different ethnic, racial, socio-economic and other subgroups performed throughout the state. Finally, to improve public transparency and empower parents, we urge the state to include assessment results on student report cards and send reports to parents directly, rather than leaving that responsibility to districts.
Regents Exams
Although we welcome increases in the percentage of students passing Regents exams, significant disparities persist. For example, 61% of all students passed the Regents Geometry exam, compared with just 37% of Black students and 42% of Latinx students. NYSED also reported passing rates of 77% on the newly introduced ELA Regents exam and 80% on the new Algebra II exam. However, the transition to new assessments and uncertainty about the role of Regents exams under NY Inspires raise important questions about how these results compare with previous years and how the state will maintain consistent, rigorous measures of student readiness as graduation requirements evolve.
Implications for NY Inspires
These assessment results also have significant implications for NY Inspires, NYSED’s initiative to change graduation requirements and transition to a competency-based education system. Only 46% of eighth graders demonstrated proficiency in math, while just 53% demonstrated proficiency in reading. This means that roughly half of the state’s students enter high school without the foundational skills they need to meaningfully engage in the innovative learning experiences NY Inspires envisions.
These outcomes reinforce EdTrust-New York’s recommendation that the state delay NY Inspires implementation by two years. This delay would give the state time to address equity concerns and strengthen current middle school students’ reading and math skills so they can succeed in high school.
The Need for Greater State Accountability
Taken together, the assessment results underscore the need for state leaders, including the Board of Regents, the Legislature, and the Governor, to act with greater urgency and accountability. State leaders must prioritize significant new investments in reading and math in the 2027 state budget and pass legislation to establish a statewide longitudinal data system.
We look forward to working with state leaders to improve student outcomes and restore confidence in the New York’s assessment system.
###
About EdTrust-New York:
EdTrust-New York is dedicated to eliminating equity and opportunity gaps that hinder students from reaching their full potential. We focus on ensuring that all students, especially Black, Latinx, Native American, and Asian American and Pacific Islander students and those from low-income backgrounds achieve high levels of success from early childhood through college. For more information, visit EdTrustNY.org.
